The Evidence Behind Using Compression Garments, Massage, and Supplements for Plastic Surgery Patient Recovery
Plastic surgery patients are often told to wear compression garments, massage scars, or take supplements to aid recovery. But how much of this advice is based on evidence, and how much is tradition or marketing?
For nurses in private practice, understanding the scientific evidence behind these interventions ensures patients receive clear, safe, and effective recommendations. This article examines what the research says about compression, massage, and supplements, and how nurses can guide patients toward best practice.
Compression Garments: What the Evidence Shows
Compression garments are standard in procedures such as liposuction, abdominoplasty, breast surgery, and body contouring.
Benefits
Reduce post-operative swelling and edema by promoting lymphatic drainage.
Support tissues and help re-drape skin after fat removal or contouring.
Provide comfort by reducing wound tension.
May reduce seroma formation after abdominoplasty or liposuction.
Evidence
Randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews show that compression reduces swelling and bruising in the first 2–6 weeks after surgery.
Evidence for improved long-term scar quality or final contour is mixed — support is mostly for early recovery benefits.
Excessive or poorly fitted compression can impair healing or cause pressure injuries.
Clinical Guidelines
Typically recommended for 4–6 weeks post-op, sometimes longer for extensive liposuction or contouring.
Must be fitted properly to avoid folds, pressure areas, or impaired circulation.
Massage: Scar and Lymphatic Drainage
Scar Massage
Aim: soften scar tissue, improve pliability, and reduce thickness.
Evidence: moderate quality evidence supports silicone plus massage in reducing hypertrophic scarring.
Should begin once wound is closed and fully healed (usually 2–3 weeks post-op).
Technique: circular motions with moderate pressure, 5–10 minutes, 2–3 times daily.
Manual Lymphatic Drainage (MLD)
Aim: reduce swelling, bruising, and discomfort after liposuction or abdominoplasty.
Evidence: studies show short-term benefits in swelling reduction, though long-term outcome differences are less clear.
Safe when performed by trained therapists; inappropriate pressure can cause harm.
Supplements & Nutrition: Sorting Fact from Fiction
Patients often ask about supplements for healing. Evidence varies widely.
Supported by Evidence
Vitamin C – important for collagen synthesis and immune function. Deficiency impairs healing.
Zinc – required for tissue repair and immune defense, but excess can impair copper absorption.
Vitamin D – low levels are linked to slower healing.
Protein supplements – support recovery if diet is inadequate.
Limited or Weak Evidence
Vitamin E – popular for scars but evidence is weak, and topical use may cause dermatitis.
Bromelain and Arnica – some studies suggest reduced bruising and swelling, but evidence is inconsistent.
Collagen powders – widely marketed but limited clinical data on wound healing benefit.
Safety Concerns
Supplements can interact with anesthesia and medications (e.g., fish oil, ginkgo, garlic increase bleeding risk).
Always check with the surgeon before starting any supplement.
Do’s and Don’ts of Compression, Massage, and Supplements
Do’s
Do ensure compression garments are properly fitted and worn consistently.
Do educate patients on gradual weaning off garments rather than abrupt stopping.
Do encourage scar massage once wounds are healed.
Do teach correct massage technique and pressure.
Do support balanced nutrition and evidence-based supplements like vitamin C and zinc.
Do warn patients about unproven supplements that claim “miracle” healing.
Do document patient education and compliance.
Don’ts
Don’t allow patients to wear garments that are too tight or folded.
Don’t start massage before wounds are sealed.
Don’t recommend supplements without considering drug interactions.
Don’t promise that massage will “erase” scars — it improves, not eliminates.
Don’t rely solely on supplements when nutrition is inadequate.
Don’t overlook psychosocial reassurance — patients need guidance as well as instructions.
FAQs on Compression, Massage, and Supplements
Compression Garments
Q: How long should compression garments be worn?
Most surgeons recommend 4–6 weeks, but duration may vary by procedure.
Q: Can compression be harmful?
Yes, if too tight or ill-fitting, it can cause skin breakdown or impair circulation.
Q: Should patients sleep in compression garments?
Yes, in the early weeks, unless otherwise directed by the surgeon.
Massage
Q: When can scar massage begin?
Once wounds are fully closed and no scabs remain, usually 2–3 weeks post-op.
Q: Does massage really improve scars?
Yes, it improves pliability and comfort, though silicone has stronger evidence.
Q: Is lymphatic drainage always necessary?
Not for every patient, but it can reduce swelling after large-volume liposuction or tummy tuck.
Supplements
Q: Should all patients take supplements?
Not necessarily. A balanced diet often provides enough, but vitamin C, zinc, or protein may help if deficiencies exist.
Q: Does vitamin E help scars?
Evidence is weak, and some patients develop skin irritation.
Q: Are herbal remedies safe?
Many (like ginkgo, garlic, ginseng) can increase bleeding risk and should be stopped pre-op.
Patient Concerns
Q: Why do patients resist wearing garments?
They may feel hot, restricted, or itchy. Nurses should emphasize comfort strategies and explain the benefits.
Q: Do supplements speed up recovery significantly?
No supplement replaces rest, nutrition, and proper wound care. They are supportive, not curative.
Q: Should massage hurt?
No. Gentle pressure is effective; pain may indicate too much force or premature timing.
Medical Evidence for Compression, Massage, Nutrition & Scar Management
References for Compression & Silicone
Arkoubi et al., 2024 (JPRAS Open)
Systematic review – compression garments may help reduce swelling and improve comfort, but evidence for preventing seroma is limited. Takeaway: Good for early recovery support, not a guaranteed solution for seroma. https://www.jprasopen.com/article/S2352-5878(24)00078-0/fulltext
Brown et al., 2023 (Aesthetic Plastic Surgery)
Drains + compression garments lowered seroma risk more than progressive tension sutures alone. Takeaway: Compression is most effective when combined with drains or sutures. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00266-022-03244-4
de Moraes Fontes et al., 2023 (Aesthetic Surgery Journal)
RCT – compression garments reduced edema after abdominoplasty, but excessive compression increased abdominal pressure. Takeaway: Fit garments carefully; reduce swelling without compromising safety. https://doi.org/10.1093/asj/sjac273
Wiseman et al., 2020 (Clinical Rehabilitation)
RCT – pediatric burn scars improved more with silicone + pressure garments than with either alone. Takeaway: Combination therapy is best for hypertrophic scar prevention. https://doi.org/10.1177/0269215519877516
Waibel et al., 2021 (Dermatology and Therapy)
RCT – silicone gel with copaiba oil improved color, contour, and texture of scars vs placebo. Takeaway: Enhanced silicone formulations may offer additional benefit. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13555-021-00634-5
van den Kerckhove et al., 2022 (Journal of Bodywork & Movement Therapies)
Massage reduced pain and stiffness in post-surgical scars. Takeaway: Encourage massage for comfort and mobility, while managing expectations. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0894113022000059
Pezeshki et al., 2022 (JPRAS)
RCT – early mechanical stimulation (massage/manual therapy) improved mastectomy scar appearance within 2 months. Takeaway: Early, gentle scar mobilization may improve cosmetic outcomes. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877065722000963
Sangha et al., 2024 (Clinical and Experimental Dermatology)
Review – wound healing and scar management approaches include massage, silicone, compression; must be individualized. Takeaway: Tailor scar management to patient risk factors and healing profile. https://academic.oup.com/ced/article/49/4/325/7450282
Wounds Australia Standards for Wound Prevention and Management (4th Edition, 2023) – clinical framework on safe wound care and recovery.
Cochrane Reviews – on compression therapy and manual lymphatic drainage.
Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery – studies on compression and scar outcomes.
Advances in Skin & Wound Care (Lippincott) – reviews on scar massage and adjunctive therapies.
American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) Patient Safety Statements – guidance on supplements, medications, and perioperative risk.
British Journal of Surgery – systematic reviews on post-operative compression garment effectiveness.
Clinical Nutrition Journal – evidence on micronutrients and wound healing.
Taking Action and Implementing
Compression garments, scar massage, and supplements are three of the most common post-operative questions nurses face. By understanding the evidence, nurses can separate fact from fiction, promote safety, and reassure patients with confidence.
The best approach is balanced: compression and massage can support recovery when done correctly, but they must be personalized to patient tolerance and wound status. Supplements should be recommended only when evidence supports them, and always with safety in mind.
By providing clear, evidence-based education, nurses strengthen patient trust and ensure recovery is guided by science — not myths.
Specialist Practice Excellence provides Mentoring and Training on Practice Operations, Patient Lead
Generation & Enquiry Conversion for Specialist Surgeon practices in Australia, UK and USA.
Meet the Team
David Staughton
David Staughton is a Melbourne-based business growth strategist, keynote speaker, and certified consultant with 30+ years of experience across multiple industries. He helps specialist surgeons and small businesses improve operations, increase revenue, and build strong teams. David has delivered 750+ talks worldwide and holds CSP and CCEO credentials.
Michelle
Michelle Staughton is a highly experienced Practice Consultant and Operations Coach who specialises in helping specialist medical and surgical practices run more smoothly and efficiently. With extensive experience in healthcare management, she focuses on improving patient experience, streamlining clinic operations, and supporting practice growth.
Brooklyn
Brooklyn has over 8 years of experience in specialty consulting, focusing on business improvement and customer experience. She has worked in Reception, Enquiries, Consulting, and Accounts, giving her a strong understanding of the customer journey. As a mentor, she designs training programs that help teams deliver excellent service with confidence.
What We Do
SPE helps Specialist Surgeons to:
Improve practice operations
Manage time effectively
Grow income sustainably
Build stronger teams and better patient experiences
